The brief arrives on a Tuesday: a new primary school extension for a county council, design team appointment, RIBA stages listed in the scope, a quality-price split published in the notice. The practice has designed three schools in the last decade. It has the drawings, the photographs, the client letters. And yet the director looks at the quality questionnaire and sees something that bears no relation to how architects normally win work.
There is no space for a design competition entry. No room for a concept sketch. Instead there are questions about resourcing, programme management, quality assurance, stakeholder engagement, sustainability approach and social value, each with a word limit and a score out of five. The portfolio, which is how most practices think about their credibility, is reduced to a few case study slots with a template that asks for contract value, dates and a client contact.
That gap between how architects present themselves and how public buyers score them is the main reason good practices lose public work. This guide sets out what buyers in the UK public sector are actually evaluating when they appoint an architectural or design consultancy, which quality questions carry the weight, what portfolio evidence scores and what does not, and how a small practice can bid without pulling its senior designers off live projects for a fortnight.
Why public design appointments look different
Private clients often choose an architect on a conversation, a portfolio and a sense of fit. Public buyers cannot work that way. They spend public money, they must treat bidders equally, and they have to be able to explain an award decision to an unsuccessful bidder who asks. That pushes them towards criteria they can write down in advance and score consistently.
The consequence is that design talent is rarely scored directly. What gets scored is the evidence that the practice can deliver a design service: on programme, within the cost plan, with the right people, through the statutory and stakeholder processes, and with a record of doing it for similar buyers. A beautiful building is evidence of some of that. On its own, it is evidence of none of the things the scoring sheet asks about.
This is not a criticism of buyers. A council commissioning a school extension is mostly worried about the things that go wrong on public projects: late design information, cost overruns, poor coordination with engineers, planning delays, a lead designer who disappears after the interview. The quality questions are written to test for those risks. Read them that way and the questionnaire starts to make more sense.
A useful reframe: the buyer is not asking whether you are a good architect. It is asking whether appointing you is a safe decision it can defend.
The routes public design work comes through
Before the questions, it helps to know where the opportunities sit, because the route changes what you are asked and how hard the competition is.
- Open or competitive tenders. A single appointment advertised on a public portal. Common for one-off projects, especially from councils, academy trusts, colleges and housing associations.
- Frameworks. Many public construction and consultancy appointments run through frameworks, where a panel of suppliers is appointed and projects are then awarded by mini-competition or direct award. Getting onto the framework is the competitive moment. After that, the work comes through call-offs.
- Below-threshold quotations. Smaller commissions, such as feasibility studies or condition surveys, may be procured through a request for quotation with a short quality element.
- Design competitions. Less common, and usually reserved for projects where the design itself is the point. They have their own rules and costs and are not the focus here.
For most practices, frameworks and open tenders are where the volume is. If your market is mainly framework-led, the bid that matters most may be one you submit every few years to get on the panel, followed by much shorter mini-competition responses. Our guide to frameworks, dynamic purchasing systems and open tenders covers how those routes differ.
Selection first: the stage practices underestimate
Many design appointments include a selection stage before the quality questions, either as a separate questionnaire or as pass/fail sections within the tender. Practices lose here more often than they would like to admit, usually on paperwork rather than capability.
What is typically checked
- Professional indemnity insurance. Buyers set a minimum level, often linked to the project value and risk. Check the level, whether it is per claim or aggregate, and whether you need to confirm you will hold it at the point of appointment or already hold it. Our article on insurance requirements in tenders covers the common forms.
- Professional registration. Buyers may ask for evidence that the lead designer and key staff are registered or chartered with the relevant bodies.
- Financial standing. Accounts, turnover thresholds or a financial ratio test. Small practices can fall foul of a turnover requirement set too high for the project, and that is worth a clarification question rather than silent withdrawal.
- Health and safety. Your health and safety policy and, for design work, how you approach designer duties under the CDM Regulations.
- Quality and environmental management. Some buyers ask for ISO certification or an equivalent documented system. See ISO certification requirements for how buyers usually frame this.
- Information security and BIM capability. Increasingly, buyers ask how you manage project information, what common data environment you use, and whether you can work to the information standards the project requires.
- Exclusion grounds and declarations. Standard, but a missed signature still scores zero.
None of this is difficult. It is just easy to leave until the last day, when the person who knows where the insurance schedule is happens to be on site.
Keep a current selection pack
The practices that get through selection reliably keep one current set: insurance certificates, registrations, accounts, policies, accreditations, staff CVs. Each document has an owner and a renewal date. When a tender lands, selection becomes assembly rather than archaeology.
The quality questions that carry the weight
Every buyer writes its own questions, so treat this as a map of the common ground rather than a list to copy. Read the weighting in the actual tender before planning anything. The highest-weighted question deserves the most of your time, even when it is not the one your practice finds most interesting.
Understanding of the brief and design approach
This is usually the question closest to what architects think of as the real work. It asks how you understand the project and how you would approach it. The temptation is to write a design philosophy. What scores is evidence that you have read this brief closely: the site constraints, the users, the budget, the programme, the stakeholders and the risks.
- Name the specific challenges in this project, not projects in general. A live school site with children on it. A listed building. A tight cost plan. Phased occupation.
- Explain how your approach responds to each, with reference to comparable work where you dealt with the same thing.
- Say what you would want to establish early, and why. Buyers notice when a bidder has spotted a risk they had not written down.
- Be careful with concept sketches. Some buyers welcome a short initial response. Others will not score anything that looks like unpaid design, and some explicitly prohibit it. Follow the instructions.
Team, resourcing and continuity
Public buyers have been burnt by bid teams that never turn up on the project. Expect questions about who will do the work, how much of their time is committed, what happens if someone leaves, and how you will cover peaks.
- Name the people. Role, registration, relevant experience and their part in comparable projects.
- Show the time commitment and be realistic. An evaluator comparing a principal promised at fifty per cent with one promised at ten per cent will believe neither unless the resourcing plan supports it.
- Explain continuity: deputies, handover arrangements, how project knowledge is recorded so it does not live in one person's head.
- If you rely on subconsultants, such as structural engineers, landscape architects or cost consultants, say who they are, how long you have worked together and how you coordinate. Our guide to subcontractor management covers what buyers look for here.
Programme and design management
Late design information is one of the most common complaints on public projects. Buyers ask how you will manage the design programme, coordinate the design team, manage change and keep to key dates such as planning submission and tender issue.
Strong answers describe the actual mechanisms: design team meetings, information release schedules, change control, how design responsibility is allocated, how you track and close actions. If you work to the RIBA Plan of Work, say how you map deliverables to its stages for this project rather than reciting it. Evaluators have read the Plan of Work. They want to see you apply it.
Cost management and value
Design decisions drive cost, and buyers know it. Expect questions about how you design to a budget, work with the cost consultant, test options and respond when the cost plan comes back over.
A specific example earns more than a general statement. A project where an early cost check showed the scheme was over budget, the options you tested, the decision the client took and the outcome. Do not invent figures. If you cannot share numbers, describe the process and the result in plain terms.
Quality assurance and design checking
How do you make sure drawings and specifications are right before they go out? Buyers ask about internal review, checking procedures, sign-off authority and how lessons from past projects feed back. If you hold a certified quality management system, refer to it and explain what it means in practice on a project. If you do not, describe the system you actually run.
Stakeholder engagement and consultation
Public projects have many stakeholders: end users, governors, residents, planning officers, ward members, building users with particular needs. Buyers want to know how you will engage them, how you manage conflicting views and how you record decisions.
The best answers describe methods matched to the audience. Workshops with staff. Plain-language material for residents. Short sessions with pupils. A clear route for agreeing decisions with the client so that consultation does not reopen settled questions every month.
Sustainability and net zero
Design consultancies are often asked how they will reduce operational and embodied carbon, meet the buyer's sustainability targets, and approach standards such as BREEAM or Passivhaus where they apply. Some buyers set specific targets in the brief, and the answer must respond to those, not to the practice's general position.
Evidence matters more here than anywhere. Name projects where you achieved a rating or measured an outcome, and say what the design decisions were. If you are newer to a particular standard, say what training or experience your team has and how you would bring in specialist support. Overclaiming on sustainability is easy to spot and easy to challenge.
Accessibility and inclusive design
Particularly on schools, healthcare and civic buildings, buyers ask how you will design for users with different needs. Describe how inclusive design is built into your process, how you consult users with lived experience, and examples where it changed the design.
Digital working and BIM
Where the project requires information modelling, buyers ask about your software, information standards, model coordination and how you work in a shared environment with other consultants. Be specific about what you do now. A practice that coordinates well in two dimensions and is honest about it often scores better than one that claims full capability and cannot evidence it.
Social value
Social value is now a scored element in many public tenders. For a design practice, credible commitments might include work experience and placements for students, engagement with local schools about careers in the built environment, pro bono advice to community groups, local employment within your supply chain or design that delivers wider benefit to the community. Commitments should be measurable and proportionate to the size of the appointment and your practice. See social value tender questions for how these are usually scored.
Portfolio evidence: what scores and what does not
The portfolio is where architects feel most confident and where bids most often miss the marks available. The reason is simple. A portfolio is designed to show what you designed. A case study in a tender is designed to prove you can deliver what this buyer needs.
Choose relevance over prestige
Your most admired building is not necessarily your best case study. A modest refurbishment of an occupied school, delivered on budget with a phased programme, may score far higher on a school extension tender than an award-winning private house. Evaluators look for similarity in building type, client type, scale, procurement route, constraints and value.
When choosing, ask for each candidate project:
- Is the client similar? Public sector, same type of body, similar governance.
- Is the building similar? Use, size, new build or refurbishment.
- Were the constraints similar? Occupied site, heritage, tight budget, complex stakeholders.
- Was the appointment similar? Stages covered, role, procurement route, contract form.
- Can you evidence the outcome? Programme, budget, rating, client feedback.
- Were the proposed team members involved?
That last one matters. A case study delivered by people who have since left the practice is weaker evidence, and some evaluators will check.
Structure each case study to the question
If the buyer provides a template, use it exactly. If not, a reliable structure is:
- The project in one line. Client, building type, value, stages, dates.
- The challenge. What made it difficult, in terms the buyer recognises.
- What you did. Your specific actions and decisions, not the building's features.
- The outcome. Delivered to programme, cost, quality or rating, stated only as far as you can evidence.
- Relevance. One or two sentences tying it back to this tender.
- Who was involved. The named team members who are also proposed here.
Our guide on how to write case studies goes further on structure, and how to present case studies covers layout and length.
Images: where they help and where they do not
Some tenders allow images and some do not. Some count images within page limits. Read the instructions carefully, because a well-designed submission that breaks the formatting rules can lose marks or be ruled non-compliant.
Where images are allowed, use them as evidence rather than decoration. A plan showing how you phased works around an occupied building tells an evaluator more than a hero photograph. A caption that states the point being made is worth adding.
References and client feedback
Buyers may contact referees. Choose clients who will answer, brief them in advance and make sure their contact details are current. If you quote client feedback in a case study, use only what the client actually said, with their permission. Paraphrased praise attributed to a client is a risk you do not need.
Answering without the perfect precedent
Smaller practices often lack a directly comparable public project. That is not automatically fatal. Draw on transferable experience: a private school project for an education tender, a complex refurbishment for a heritage tender, or work your proposed team did at a previous practice, clearly described as such. Explain what transfers and how you would manage the differences. Our article on answering quality questions without direct experience covers this in more depth.
Fee bids: pricing a design appointment
Design fees in public tenders may be requested as a lump sum, a percentage of construction cost, a fee per stage or a combination with hourly rates for additional services. The pricing schedule will say which.
A few points apply across forms:
- Price the scope written down, not the one you expect. If the brief covers stages you would not normally take on, or excludes ones you would, price accordingly and raise a clarification if the scope is unclear.
- Tie the fee to the resourcing plan. If the quality answer commits a senior architect at a certain level of involvement, the fee has to fund it. Evaluators compare the two.
- Watch the assumptions. Number of design team meetings, site visits, planning iterations, consultation events and option studies. Unstated assumptions become unpaid work.
- Check how price is scored. Under relative scoring, a low bid elsewhere can compress your price score regardless of what you do. On many design appointments quality carries most of the weight, so a lower fee rarely compensates for weak quality answers.
- Be wary of abnormally low fees. Buyers may challenge a fee that looks too low to deliver the service, and a practice that wins on an unsustainable fee carries the loss for the whole appointment.
Our guide to tender pricing covers cost build, scoring methods and inflation risk in more detail.
Interviews and presentations
Design appointments sometimes include a shortlist interview. This is where the practice's design thinking can come through in person, and it is often scored separately.
- Bring the people you named. Swapping in a stronger presenter who will not work on the project is noticed.
- Answer the questions set. If the buyer issues interview questions in advance, structure the presentation around them.
- Be consistent with the written bid. An interview that promises more than the tender undermines both.
- Keep time. Overrunning leaves no room for the panel's questions, which is where much of the scoring happens.
Deciding which appointments to chase
A small practice cannot bid for everything, and should not try. The cost of a response falls mainly on senior staff whose time would otherwise be billed. A bid that was never winnable is a cost with nothing to show for it.
Before committing, ask:
- Do we have relevant evidence? At least two or three case studies that fit, with team members still in the practice.
- Can we resource it if we win? Against the current workload and the programme in the brief.
- Can we meet the selection requirements? Insurance levels, turnover, accreditations.
- Does the fee basis work? Given the scope and the likely level of competition.
- Do we know anything about this buyer? Past appointments, existing frameworks, an incumbent.
- Is it worth the time to respond? Weighed against what else that time could do.
Our bid/no-bid analysis guide sets this out as a structured decision.
Common mistakes in design consultancy bids
Writing to impress rather than to score
Practices with strong design writing sometimes produce elegant prose that does not address the question. Evaluators score against the question and the published criteria. A sentence that does not help them award a mark is using up words that could.
Generic answers reused without adjustment
Reusing good material is sensible. Reusing it without changing the project names, the buyer's priorities or the examples is not. An answer that mentions the wrong council is an obvious failure. An answer that ignores this project's constraints is a quieter one, and just as costly.
Missing the instructions
Font sizes, page limits, image rules, file formats, whether appendices are read. Design practices are used to controlling presentation. In a tender, the buyer controls it.
Overpromising on team and sustainability
Commitments in a bid usually become contractual. A director at forty per cent, a target rating, a set number of consultation events: if you would not want to be held to it, do not write it.
Not asking for feedback
Win or lose, ask for the scores and comments. Feedback on design appointments is often specific enough to improve the next bid directly. See what to do after you lose a tender.
Building the material once
The pattern across design consultancy tenders is that the same questions recur in different words: team and resourcing, design management, quality assurance, stakeholder engagement, sustainability, social value, health and safety, information management. The answers differ by project, but the evidence behind them does not change much from one bid to the next.
Practices that bid well treat that evidence as an asset. They keep a structured set of case studies, CVs, policies, past answers and feedback, and they update it after each submission. Then a new tender starts with tailoring rather than writing. Our guide to building a bid content library covers how to organise one.
That is the approach Bidwell takes. It reads the bids, policies and case studies a practice has already written, or its website, builds a knowledge base of its own answers, and drafts each new tender question from that material, showing the source document for every answer so the team can check it before anything goes to a buyer. The design thinking and the final judgement stay with the practice.
The short version
Public buyers appointing architects and design consultants rarely score design talent directly. They score the evidence that appointing you is a safe decision: the right team, committed and named; a clear method for managing the design programme and cost; credible sustainability and stakeholder approaches; and case studies chosen for relevance rather than prestige.
Read the weighting first. Pass selection with a current pack of documents. Answer the brief in front of you rather than describing your practice in general. Structure portfolio evidence around the challenge, your actions and the outcome. Price the fee to fund what you promised. Ask for feedback every time. Practices that do these things consistently find that public work stops feeling like a different discipline and starts looking like what it is: another client, with its own way of deciding.

