The email arrives with a subject line that gives it away before you open it. Thank you for your submission. On this occasion you have not been successful. Somewhere below that sits a table of scores, or a paragraph of comments, or sometimes almost nothing at all. The team that spent evenings on the bid reads it once, sighs, and moves on to the next deadline.
That moment, straight after a loss, is when most firms are most willing to change how they bid. It is also when they are least likely to do anything structured about it, because the next tender is already open on someone's screen. This guide sets out what to do in the days after a loss: how to read what the buyer sent, how to ask for more if it is thin, how to work out where the marks actually went, and how to turn that into answers that are better next time rather than a vague resolution to try harder.
First, Read the Outcome Letter Properly
Before anything else, read the whole letter slowly, ideally with the original tender pack beside it. Outcome letters vary a great deal between buyers, but most contain some combination of the following:
- Your scores. Per question, per section, or as a total for quality and price.
- The winning bidder's scores. Sometimes per question, sometimes only as totals.
- The name of the winning bidder. Often included, sometimes withheld.
- Comments on your answers. Ranging from detailed reasoning to a single line.
- A standstill period. For many above-threshold public contracts there is a pause between the award decision and the contract being signed. Check the letter for the dates.
The standstill point matters more than people realise. If you think the evaluation was wrong, not just disappointing, that period is usually when you can raise it. You do not need to decide in the first hour, but you should know the date before it passes. If you are unsure what applies to a particular procurement, check the tender documents and, where the stakes justify it, take proper advice rather than relying on a blog post.
Practical rule: Note the standstill end date in your calendar the day the letter arrives, even if you have no intention of challenging.
Then separate what the letter tells you into two kinds of information. Facts: the scores, the weightings, the winner. Opinions: the evaluator's comments. Both are useful, but you will use them differently.
Work Out Whether You Lost on Quality, Price or a Gate
A loss is rarely about the whole bid. It usually comes down to one of three things, and the fix for each is different.
| Where you lost | What it looks like in the scores | Where the work goes next |
|---|---|---|
| A pass or fail gate | Your quality answers were not scored, or the letter says a mandatory requirement was not met | Your compliance process, your evidence library and your bid or no-bid decision |
| Quality | Your quality total trails the winner, often on a handful of heavily weighted questions | The specific answers that dropped marks, and the evidence behind them |
| Price | Quality is close or ahead, price score is well behind | Your cost model, your assumptions and whether this kind of contract suits you |
Do the arithmetic yourself. Take the weightings from the tender documents and work out how many weighted marks separated you from the winner on quality and on price. A firm that lost by two weighted marks on quality and eight on price has a pricing question, however much the comments on its method statement sting. A firm that matched the winner on price and lost twelve marks across three quality answers has a writing and evidence question.
If you were excluded at a gate, treat that as the most urgent lesson. A missing insurance level, an expired certificate or an unsigned declaration costs the whole bid, and it is the easiest kind of loss to prevent next time. Our guide to the bid review checklist covers the compliance checks that catch these before submission.
Find the Questions That Cost You
Where you have per-question scores, line them up against the winner's if you have them, and against the maximum available if you do not. Then rank the gaps by weighted marks, not raw marks. A one-point drop on a question worth a large share of the quality score matters more than a two-point drop on a lightly weighted one.
You will often find the losses concentrated. Three or four questions account for most of the gap, and the rest are close. That is good news. It means you do not need to rewrite your whole approach to bidding. You need to fix a small number of answers, and probably the evidence behind them.
For each question on your shortlist, put three things side by side:
- The question as the buyer wrote it, including every sub-part.
- The scoring descriptor for the top band and for the band you landed in.
- Your submitted answer, exactly as sent.
Read your answer as if you were the evaluator holding that descriptor. This is uncomfortable, and it is the most useful hour you will spend after a loss. You will usually see the problem before you read a single feedback comment: a sub-part that got one line, a claim with no evidence beside it, an opening that talks about the company instead of the question, a commitment that sounds like intent rather than method.
Reading Evaluator Comments Without Over-Reading Them
Evaluator comments are short, written under time pressure, and often phrased in the language of the scoring scale. That makes them easy to misread in both directions. Some firms take every comment as a verdict on the business. Others dismiss them because the evaluator obviously did not read the answer properly.
A more useful approach is to translate each comment into the specific thing it is pointing at. Common comments and what they usually mean:
- "Limited evidence provided." There were claims without a case study, figure, accreditation or named process behind them. Or there was evidence, but it did not match the buyer's situation closely enough to count.
- "Did not fully address the requirement." A sub-part of the question was missed or answered thinly. Go back to the question and count the parts.
- "Generic response." The answer could have been sent to any buyer. Often a sign of reused text that was not adapted.
- "Some concerns over resourcing" or "over deliverability". The evaluator could not see who would do the work or how. Names, roles, numbers and timings were missing or vague.
- "Good understanding demonstrated." On its own, this often accompanies a middle score. Understanding is not the same as a method the buyer can hold you to.
If a comment is genuinely unclear, write it down as a question to ask the buyer rather than guessing what it meant.
Treat each comment as pointing at a gap in the answer, not a judgement on the firm. Gaps can be fixed. Judgements just hurt.
When the Feedback Is Too Thin to Use
Plenty of firms receive a total score, a line saying the winner scored higher, and nothing else. That is frustrating, but it is not the end of the conversation.
Ask for more. Do it promptly, in writing, politely and specifically. A request that says "please could you provide further feedback" tends to get a general reply. A request that names questions tends to get something you can use. For example:
- For questions 3.2 and 4.1, could you tell us which aspects of the scoring descriptor our answer did not meet?
- Were there sub-parts of question 3.2 that you felt were not addressed?
- For question 4.1, was the evidence provided considered insufficient, or not relevant to the requirement?
Some buyers will offer a call or a meeting, sometimes called a debrief. If you get one, prepare as you would for a client meeting. Bring the scores, the questions you have ranked, and the specific questions you want answered. Listen more than you talk. This is not the place to argue the scores; it is the place to learn what the evaluators were looking for. Our article on what a debriefing meeting is covers how these usually run.
If the buyer will not give more, you still have the scoring descriptors and your own answer. The self-marking exercise above will tell you a great deal, even without comments.
Should You Challenge the Decision?
Most losses should not be challenged. A lower score on a question you answered thinly is not an error in the process, however much effort went into the bid. Challenging a fair decision uses time, can sour a relationship with a buyer you will want to bid to again, and rarely changes the outcome.
There are situations where it is worth looking harder. Typical examples include scoring that does not appear to follow the published criteria, an arithmetical error in the totals, a mandatory requirement applied to you but apparently not to others, or a criterion used in evaluation that was never published. If you see something like that, raise it with the buyer during the standstill period and get proper advice if the contract value justifies it.
For everything else, the most valuable response to a loss is a better bid next time.
Turn the Lessons Into Better Answers, Not Better Intentions
This is the step most firms skip. They read the feedback, agree with some of it, and resolve to write stronger answers. Then the next tender arrives, someone opens the last bid, copies the same answers across, and the same marks drop again.
The lessons from a loss only help if they change the material you start from. That means editing the stored version of each answer, not just remembering what went wrong.
For each question on your shortlist, work through these steps:
- Rewrite the answer against the top-band descriptor. Not the old answer with a few words changed. Start from the descriptor and ask what an answer earning it would contain.
- Fix the evidence first. If the comment was about limited evidence, writing is not the problem. Find the case study, the performance record, the procedure or the certificate that supports the claim. If you do not have it, that is a gap in the business's evidence, not the bid.
- Turn intent into method. Every "we are committed to" becomes who does what, how often, using what, and what happens when it goes wrong. Only write what is true of how you actually work.
- Record what the buyer said. Keep the score and the comment with the answer, so whoever reuses it next knows its history.
- Date it and store it once. One improved version, in one place, that the next bid starts from.
That last step is where the improvement lasts or disappears. If the better answer lives in a folder named after the lost tender, the next bidder will probably never find it.
A worked example
Take a hypothetical facilities firm that lost a council cleaning contract. The quality scores show it lost most of its marks on a question about how it would maintain standards across multiple sites. The feedback says: limited evidence of monitoring; escalation process unclear.
The original answer described a commitment to high standards, mentioned regular inspections and said issues would be addressed promptly. Reading it against the top-band descriptor, the gaps are plain. No frequency of inspection. No named role. No description of what an inspection checks. No escalation route. No reporting to the client.
The firm does run audits. It just never wrote them down in a form a bid could use. So the rewrite starts with operations: the area supervisor audits each site on a set schedule against a checklist; scores below a threshold go to the contract manager; the client gets a report on a fixed cycle. The firm adds a short example from an existing private contract, described accurately as private, showing the process working. The answer now contains a method the evaluator can picture and score.
That version, with the council's feedback recorded beside it, becomes the firm's standard answer to monitoring questions. It still needs tailoring to each buyer. But it no longer starts from the version that lost.
Fix the Evidence Library, Not Just the Answer
Many losses trace back to evidence, and evidence problems are rarely confined to one question. If one answer dropped marks because a case study was old, check every other answer that uses it. If a comment flagged an expired certificate, check the expiry dates of everything you cite.
A quick evidence review after each loss:
- Case studies. Are they current, accurate, and described in terms that match the buyers you bid to? Do they record context, such as sector, scale and conditions, not only results? Our guide on how to write case studies covers what makes them reusable.
- Policies and procedures. Do they describe what you actually do? Is there a written version of processes you run informally?
- Certificates and accreditations. Are they in date, and is the renewal date visible wherever they are stored?
- CVs. Are the people named still with you, and in the roles you describe?
- Performance data. Do you have figures you can stand behind for the measures buyers keep asking about? If not, can you start recording them now?
The last item is often the most valuable long-term change. If evaluators keep asking about response times, complaint handling or audit results, and you keep answering without numbers, start tracking those numbers on current contracts. In six months you will have evidence that did not exist when you lost.
Revisit the Bid Decision Itself
Some losses are not about the writing at all. They are about bidding for the wrong contract. Feedback is a chance to check the decision as well as the answers.
Questions worth asking honestly:
- Did the contract suit our scale, or were we stretching to a size the evaluators could see we had not handled?
- Did the scoring weight past experience heavily in an area where our record is thin?
- Was the price competitive for us, or were we always going to be undercut on this type of work?
- Did we have enough time to write it properly, or did we start late and rush?
- Was there an incumbent, and did we have any realistic reason to think the buyer wanted a change?
None of these means you were wrong to bid. Some contracts are worth a speculative attempt. But if the same pattern shows up across several losses, it should change which tenders you go for. Our bid/no-bid template gives you a structured way to make that call, and the tender readiness checker points at the things most likely to be holding a firm back.
Keep a Simple Loss Log
One loss tells you about one buyer. Several losses, recorded the same way, tell you about your bidding. A short log, kept for every result, win or lose, is enough. It does not need to be elaborate.
| Field | What to record |
|---|---|
| Tender | Buyer, contract, sector, rough size |
| Result | Won, lost, excluded, and position if known |
| Quality versus price | Weighted gap to the winner on each |
| Weakest questions | The two or three that cost most, by topic |
| Feedback themes | Evidence, resourcing, generic, missed sub-parts |
| Changes made | Which stored answers or evidence were updated |
After a handful of entries, patterns show. Perhaps social value answers are consistently weak. Perhaps mobilisation always scores well. Perhaps you keep losing on price in one sector and winning on quality in another. That is the information that should shape where you put effort, and it only exists if someone writes it down each time.
Record wins too. A winning answer and its score are just as useful as a losing one, and arguably more so, because they show what a buyer was willing to reward.
Where Software Helps, and Where It Does Not
Nothing in this process needs software. A shared folder, a spreadsheet and the discipline to update them will do it. The difficulty for small firms is rarely knowing what to do; it is finding the time to do it while also delivering the work and writing the next bid.
That is the problem Bidwell is built around. It reads the bids, policies and case studies you have already written and turns them into a knowledge base of your own answers, which you can search and export whenever you want. When you improve an answer after a loss, the improved version is what the next draft draws from, and each drafted answer shows the document it came from, so you can see whether it is the old version or the new one. The knowledge base is free; drafting tenders from it is £20 a month if you choose to switch it on. A person still reviews and signs every bid.
Software cannot do the self-marking exercise for you, decide whether to challenge, or produce evidence you do not hold. It can make sure the better answer is the one you start from next time.
A Checklist for the Week After a Loss
- Outcome letter read in full, with the tender pack beside it.
- Standstill end date noted.
- Weighted gap to the winner worked out for quality and for price.
- Any gate failure identified and its cause fixed in your compliance checks.
- Questions ranked by weighted marks lost; shortlist of three or four.
- Each shortlisted answer re-read against the top-band descriptor.
- Comments translated into specific gaps; unclear comments turned into questions for the buyer.
- Further feedback requested in writing, naming specific questions.
- Decision made on whether anything warrants a challenge, with advice if needed.
- Shortlisted answers rewritten, evidence fixed, and stored once with the date and the feedback.
- Wider evidence library checked for the same problems.
- Bid decision reviewed against the outcome.
- Result added to the loss log.
A Loss Is a Draft of the Next Bid
Every firm that wins public sector work regularly has a pile of losses behind it. What separates them from firms that keep losing in the same way is not better luck or cleverer writing. It is that each loss changed something specific: an answer rewritten against the descriptor, a case study replaced, a process finally written down, a type of contract no longer chased.
The feedback letter is the most direct information a buyer will ever give you about how your bids are read. Spend a few hours on it while it is fresh, put the improvements where the next bid will find them, and the next tender starts a little closer to the top band than this one did.

